Choose the kind of help you actually need.
National subscriptions are strongest at continuous broker monitoring. Protect Indiana is a local, one-time safety-and-removal service. Those are different products, so price alone is not the whole comparison.
The quick comparison
- DeleteMe — a recurring service beginning at $129 a year for one person, with ongoing scans, re-removals, and quarterly reports.
- Incogni — an automated recurring service beginning at $95.88 a year on its annual Standard plan, with 420+ advertised sites.
- Optery — a useful free exposure-report tier plus paid recurring removal plans from $39 to $249 a year.
- Aura — a broad identity, credit, device-security, insurance, and data-removal bundle beginning at $12 a month billed annually.
- Protect Indiana — free scam and removal tools, a $39 authorized exposure search and case file, and optional $99/month Proactive Protection after the case file.
Where Protect Indiana fits
Protect Indiana keeps its public scam and removal tools free. Kelsie’s $39 Basic Exposure Search is a separate, authorized human research service that returns a private case file within two business days.
We do not submit removal requests for you. Proactive Protection is $99/month after the case file for continuing monitoring and hands-on work; its scope is narrower than a national broker-removal subscription.
When a subscription is the better choice
If you want a company to keep checking and re-filing hundreds of broker removals, choose a subscription that publishes the coverage you need. Protect Indiana’s guides show you how to file your own opt-outs, while Kelsie’s paid work centers on exposure research, priorities, and separately scoped follow-on help.
What is free here
You can check if your email is in a known breach, use the scam guide online or by phone, follow the first-hour scam steps, and use our people-search removal guides without paying.
Start with Kelsie — $39 Use the free guides →
Competitor details were checked August 20, 2026 against each company’s official pricing or help pages. Promotions and plan details change; follow the links on the individual comparison pages before buying.